Nursing Home Deficiencies in Ohio

Facilities in Ohio ranked by health inspection deficiencies. State average: 28.7 deficiencies (national: 9.2).

Across the 922 Medicare-certified nursing homes in Ohio, the average facility carries 28.7 total health-inspection deficiencies on its most recent CMS standard survey, compared with a national average of 9.2. A "deficiency" is a specific F-tag citation written by state surveyors during the annual federal inspection under 42 CFR §483, each citation maps to a scope-and-severity grid (A through L) that determines whether it is an isolated low-harm issue or a widespread immediate-jeopardy finding. The Ohio state-level average reflects the sum of all F-tag citations divided by the number of facilities; it does not distinguish between low-severity paperwork findings and high-severity resident-harm citations, which is why drilling into any facility's full survey report matters more than the headline count. This page uses 14,693 Medicare-certified nursing-home records from CMS Care Compare, with NPPES context where available. Every figure is traceable in the methodology.

The table below ranks up to the top 100 Ohio facilities by total deficiency count (highest first) - the goal is transparency, not a blacklist. Facilities appear with their deficiency total, complaint-based deficiencies (citations triggered by a formal complaint rather than the routine survey), fine dollar amounts, and CMS Health Inspection component rating. A high count can reflect a facility with genuine quality problems, a more aggressive state survey team, a larger bed count with more opportunities for citation, or a complaint spike in a single cycle, context matters. Conversely, a low count does not guarantee good care; facilities rarely surveyed, or recently surveyed with a favorable cycle, can look clean while problems accumulate between inspections. The state's benchmark of 28.7 deficiencies and the national benchmark of 9.2 (average score 82) are starting reference points.

Deficiencies are based on CMS Rating Cycle 1 (the most recent completed standard survey); prior cycles appear on each facility's detail page. Important: PlainDoctor presents CMS deficiency data exactly as published at data.cms.gov - we do not aggregate, re-rank, or editorialize. This table is a research tool, not medical advice, a consumer rating, or a legal conclusion about any facility. Selecting a nursing home for yourself or a loved one should include in-person visits, reading the underlying F-tag narratives in the full CMS-2567 survey reports, interviewing staff and current residents' families, and consulting licensed clinicians, hospital discharge planners, and elder-law advisors familiar with Ohio long-term care regulations.

922
Facilities
28.7
Avg Deficiencies
9.2
National Avg
82
National Avg Score

Top 100 by Deficiency Count

# Facility Deficiencies Health Rating
1 HIGHLAND OAKS HEALTH CENTER 50 1/5
2 FRANCISCAN CARE CTR SYLVANIA 50 1/5
3 COUNTRY LANE GARDENS REHAB & NURSING CTR 50 1/5
4 SAINT LUKE LUTHERAN HOME 49 1/5
5 STELLAR CARE CENTER 45 1/5
6 SAPPHIRE REHABILITATION AND CARE CENTER 44 1/5
7 GARDENS OF MAYFIELD VILLAGE 43 1/5
8 COUNTRY CLUB CENTER I 42 1/5
9 CONTINUING HEALTHCARE OF CUYAHOGA FALLS 39 N/A
10 ALTERCARE OF CANAL WINCHESTER POST-ACUTE RC 38 1/5
11 OTTERBEIN GAHANNA 38 1/5
12 GARDENS OF NORTH OLMSTED 37 1/5
13 MARIETTA HEIGHTS POST ACUTE 37 N/A
14 SALEM WEST HEALTHCARE CENTER 37 1/5
15 BETHANY NURSING HOME, INC 37 1/5
16 Galion Meadows Skilled Nursing and Rehabilitation 36 1/5
17 ROLLING HILLS REHAB AND CARE CTR 36 1/5
18 SCIOTO REHABILITATION & CARE CENTER 36 1/5
19 THE LAURELS OF GAHANNA 36 1/5
20 AYDEN HEALTHCARE OF FAIRFIELD 34 1/5
21 CONTINUING HEALTHCARE AT WILLOW HAVEN 34 1/5
22 AVENTURA AT ASSUMPTION VILLAGE 33 1/5
23 FAIR HAVEN SHELBY COUNTY 33 1/5
24 AVENUE CARE AND REHABILITATION CENTER, THE 33 1/5
25 EMBASSY OF WINCHESTER 32 1/5
26 WASHINGTON SQUARE HEALTHCARE CENTER 32 1/5
27 GRANDE OAKS 32 1/5
28 ADDISON HEIGHTS HEALTH AND REHABILITATION CENTER 32 1/5
29 JAMESTOWN PLACE HEALTH AND REHAB 31 1/5
30 ASTORIA PLACE OF CINCINNATI 31 1/5
31 BEEGHLY OAKS CENTER FOR REHABILITATION & HEALING 31 1/5
32 COUNTRY CLUB RETIREMENT CTR IV 30 1/5
33 AYDEN HEALTHCARE OF TOLEDO 30 1/5
34 VISTA CENTER, THE 30 1/5
35 DUBLIN POST ACUTE 30 1/5
36 Twinsburg Post Acute 30 1/5
37 COMMUNITY SKILLED HEALTHCARE 29 1/5
38 WARREN NURSING & REHAB 29 1/5
39 THE MERRIMAN 29 1/5
40 BELLA TERRACE REHABILITATION AND NURSING CENTER 29 1/5
41 LAURELS OF WEST COLUMBUS, THE 29 1/5
42 GOOD SHEPHERD VILLAGE 28 1/5
43 DIVINE REHABILITATION AND NURSING AT TOLEDO 28 N/A
44 AYDEN HEALTHCARE OF MADEIRA 27 1/5
45 MOTHER ANGELINE MCCRORY MANOR 27 1/5
46 NORTHRIDGE HEALTH CENTER, THE 27 1/5
47 The Pavilion at Edgefield for Nursing and Rehabili 27 1/5
48 MAJESTIC CARE OF WHITEHALL 27 1/5
49 Trotwood Health & Rehab LLC 26 1/5
50 HERITAGE THE 26 2/5
51 Cedarvale Commons Rehabilitation and Healthcare Ce 26 1/5
52 ARC AT CINCINNATI 25 1/5
53 SCHOENBRUNN HEALTHCARE 25 1/5
54 ARC AT TROTWOOD LLC 25 1/5
55 COUNTRYSIDE MANOR NURSING AND REHABILITATION LLC 25 1/5
56 MAJESTIC CARE OF PERRYSBURG 25 1/5
57 EAST PARK CARE CENTER 25 1/5
58 HARVARD GARDENS REHABILITATION & CARE CENTER 25 1/5
59 CONTINUING HEALTHCARE OF GAHANNA 25 N/A
60 WEXNER HERITAGE HOUSE 24 1/5
61 PARK VISTA NURSING AND REHAB 24 1/5
62 AYDEN HEALTHCARE OF OREGON 24 1/5
63 THREE MEADOWS POST ACUTE 24 1/5
64 SHADY LAWN NURSING HOME 24 1/5
65 WESTMORELAND PLACE 24 1/5
66 WESTERVILLE POST ACUTE. 24 1/5
67 DIXON HEALTHCARE CENTER 24 1/5
68 PICKERINGTON CARE AND REHABILITATION 24 2/5
69 DIVINE REHABILITATION AND NURSING AT SYLVANIA 24 1/5
70 Marion Valley Post Acute 24 1/5
71 GREENBRIER HEALTH CENTER 23 1/5
72 DIVINE REHABILITATION AND NURSING AT CANAL POINTE 23 1/5
73 PARK TERRACE REHABILITATION CENTER 23 1/5
74 MEADOWBROOK CARE CENTER 23 1/5
75 MUSKINGUM SKILLED NURSING & REHABILITATION 23 1/5
76 THE LAURELS OF HEATH 23 1/5
77 PRESTIGE GARDENS REHABILITATION AND NURSING CENTER 23 1/5
78 GREEN MEADOWS SKILLED NURSING AND REHAB 23 1/5
79 ASTORIA PLACE OF WATERVILLE 23 1/5
80 FOUNDATION PARK CARE CENTER 23 1/5
81 THE LAURELS OF KETTERING 23 1/5
82 LIBERTY RETIREMENT COMMUNITY OF LIMA INC 23 1/5
83 TUSCANY GARDENS 23 2/5
84 TALLMADGE HEALTH & REHAB CENTER 23 1/5
85 Jag Healthcare Mansfield 22 1/5
86 LUXE REHABILITATION AND CARE CENTER 22 1/5
87 FRANKLIN PLAZA EXTENDED CARE 22 1/5
88 ARBORS AT DELAWARE 22 1/5
89 CONTINUING HEALTHCARE OF TOLEDO 22 1/5
90 CARECORE AT MARGARET HALL 22 1/5
91 MAJESTIC CARE OF KENT 22 1/5
92 CANFIELD HEALTHCARE CENTER 22 1/5
93 PROVIDENCE CARE CENTER 22 2/5
94 Aristos Nursing and Rehabilitation 22 2/5
95 NORWOOD TOWERS POST-ACUTE 22 1/5
96 VINEYARDS AT CONCORD, THE 22 2/5
97 AVENUE AT BROADVIEW HEIGHTS 22 2/5
98 MERIT HOUSE LLC 21 1/5
99 Newark Nursing & Rehab 21 1/5
100 ALLEN VIEW HEALTHCARE CENTER 21 1/5

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average deficiency count in Ohio nursing homes?

Across 922 Medicare-certified facilities in Ohio, the average is 28.7 health inspection deficiencies per facility, compared to a national average of 9.2. The national average deficiency score is 82.

What types of deficiencies do nursing homes receive?

Deficiencies are F-tag citations issued during CMS standard surveys or complaint investigations. They range from minor paperwork issues (scope A-B) to widespread immediate-jeopardy findings (scope J-L). The severity matters more than the raw count.

How does Ohio compare nationally for nursing home deficiencies?

The Ohio average of 28.7 deficiencies per facility is above the national average of 9.2. State survey teams vary in strictness, so cross-state comparisons should be made with caution.

What should I do if a Ohio nursing home has many deficiencies?

Review the severity of individual citations, not just the count. Read the F-tag narratives in the CMS-2567 survey reports, tour the facility in person, interview staff and residents' families, and consult licensed clinicians or elder-law advisors familiar with the state's long-term care regulations.

Compare Deficiencies in Nearby States

Other states with deficiency data from the CMS-2567 inspection record for side-by-side context.

Compare specialties nationally →

Data from CMS Five-Star Quality Rating System, Nursing Home Provider Information (Feb 2026) (data.cms.gov). Deficiency counts drawn from Rating Cycle 1 (most recent standard survey) in the CMS-2567 record. Each facility tracked by its CCN. Methodology

Compiled from official public sources by the editorial process.