Bethany Cataldi, D.O.
Facial Plastic Surgery Physician · Highland, IN
Bethany Cataldi, D.O. is a facial plastic surgery physician with a practice address in Highland, Indiana, and NPI 1205890886, issued on Apr 12, 2006. Check the license (Indiana 02002695A, as entered in NPPES) on the Medical Licensing Board of Indiana; the Medicare figures below come from public CMS files.
- Name
- Bethany Cataldi
- Credential
- D.O.
- Primary taxonomy
- Facial Plastic Surgery Physician 207YS0123X
- License number
- 02002695A IN
Self-reported in NPPES; status is on the state search - Practice location
- 2203 45TH St, Highland, IN 46322
- Phone
- (219) 836-4820
- Enumerated
- Apr 12, 2006
- Record last updated
- Nov 15, 2016 (not updated in 10 years: call before relying on the address or phone)
- Fax
- (219) 836-5186
- Medicaid ID
- 200841030 A IN
- Entity
- Type 1 · individual
4 nearest facial plastic surgery physician records → All 5 in Indiana → Look up another NPI →
Verify Bethany Cataldi in five checks
- 1IdentityNPI record in CMS NPPESNPI lookupConfirmed in NPPES
- 2LicenseActive license and public ordersMedical Licensing Board of Indiana
Search for license 02002695ACheck the board - 3Other statesLicenses and actions elsewhereDocInfo (FSMB)Not checked
- 4ExclusionsMedicare and Medicaid bansHHS-OIG exclusion listNot checked
- 5CertificationBoard certificationABMS AOA NCCPA AANPNot checked
3.4 times the Medicare Part D claims of the average facial plastic surgery physician in 2024
1,245 Medicare Part D claims for 289 beneficiaries, against an average of 370 among the 532 providers of this specialty who prescribed in Part D. Brand-name drugs were 3% of claims. 13 claims were for opioids.
Most prescribed
- Montelukast Sodium165 claims
- Levocetirizine Dihydrochloride113 claims
- Prednisone106 claims
- Methylprednisolone81 claims
- Alprazolam76 claims
- Pantoprazole Sodium67 claims
Source: CMS Medicare Part D Prescribers by Provider and Drug, 2024 (data.cms.gov). Part D covers prescriptions for Medicare patients only; drugs with fewer than 11 claims are not published.
Facial Plastic Surgery Physician providers in Indiana
There are 5 facial plastic surgery physician records in Indiana.
All 5 in Indiana → Every provider in Highland → Facial Plastic Surgery Physician nationwide →
The 4 facial plastic surgery physician records with the nearest ZIP codes
- Alexander Caniglia, MDCarmel, IN 462901023513553
- Babar Sultan, MDIndianapolis, IN 462901063610301
- William Nunery, MDIndianapolis, IN 462801063410942
- Donn Chatham, M.D.New Albany, IN 471501629134739
Common questions
What is Bethany Cataldi, D.O.'s NPI number?
Bethany Cataldi, D.O.'s National Provider Identifier (NPI) is 1205890886, issued on Apr 12, 2006. An NPI identifies a provider in billing; it is not a license.
Where is Bethany Cataldi, D.O. located?
The NPPES record lists a practice address at 2203 45TH St, Highland, IN, 46322. Phone: (219) 836-4820. Providers update this record themselves, so call before visiting.
How can I verify Bethany Cataldi, D.O.'s license?
NPPES lists Indiana license number 02002695A, as entered by the provider. Search the Medical Licensing Board of Indiana at https://www.in.gov/pla/professions/physicians-home/. The NPPES record confirms identity only; the state search shows license status, expiration and public orders.
How much does Bethany Cataldi, D.O. prescribe under Medicare Part D?
In 2024, Bethany Cataldi, D.O. had 1,245 Medicare Part D claims for 289 beneficiaries; the average among facial plastic surgery physician prescribers was 370. Part D covers Medicare prescriptions only.
Source: CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES), file of Aug 9, 2026 (NPPES files on CMS.gov); NUCC Health Care Provider Taxonomy. Medicare files from data.cms.gov. An NPI identifies who bills; it is not a license.
Figures on PlainDoctor are read from the federal files each page names (CMS NPPES, Medicare Part D, MIPS, Open Payments; the HHS-OIG exclusion list only as counts) and from Census population estimates, with the file date shown beside them. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error. Data current as of Aug 9, 2026.