Indiana Medicare Prescriber Rankings

26,000 prescribers · $6227.6M total drug cost · Verify with CMS →

Indiana is represented in the CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber Public Use File (calendar year 2023) by 26,000 prescribers, who collectively wrote 37,138,015 prescription claims totaling $6227.6M in drug costs. Averaged across the state roster, that works out to roughly $240K in Part D drug cost per prescriber. The Part D PUF covers only Medicare Part D, prescriptions filled through commercial insurance, Medicaid, VA, TriCare, or cash payment are excluded, and CMS suppresses any prescriber-drug-beneficiary combination with fewer than 11 beneficiaries for patient privacy, which means the tables below understate low-volume activity and omit some specialty clinics entirely. According to the CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber data and the National Provider Identifier Registry, covering 2023 prescribing for more than 1 million U.S. clinicians since the benefit began in January 2006, you can search and compare here, every figure traces to its source in our methodology.

The opioid prescribing picture in Indiana is anchored by an average prescriber-level opioid rate of 8.0% against the national average of 6.4%, with 10273 prescribers in the state having written at least one Part D opioid claim during 2023. Opioid rate is calculated by CMS as opioid claims divided by total claims for that prescriber, so a low-volume pain specialist can show a high rate while a high-volume primary-care physician writing occasional short-course scripts shows a low rate, raw rate alone does not indicate clinical appropriateness, and CMS explicitly cautions against using the PUF for quality judgments. The top-cost tables spotlight prescribers whose 2023 Part D drug spend was highest in Indiana; these are typically oncologists, rheumatologists, and specialists managing high-cost biologics, not an indicator of over-prescribing.

Drill into any provider in the rankings below to see their full NPPES record, credentials, and detailed prescribing breakdown including brand/generic mix, beneficiary demographics, and most-prescribed drugs. Important: PlainDoctor presents the CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber PUF exactly as published, without editorial ranking or quality judgment. These tables are a data-transparency resource, not medical advice, not an indictment, not a quality ranking, and not a substitute for clinical judgment. Opioid prescribing decisions are nuanced medical acts, and a high PUF rate reflects only the composition of a specific prescriber's 2023 Medicare Part D claims, not patient outcomes, treatment necessity, or compliance with CDC opioid prescribing guidelines. Always verify credentials through the NPPES NPI Registry and the Indiana medical board before drawing conclusions.

26,000
Prescribers
$6227.6M
Total Drug Cost
$240K
Avg Cost / Prescriber
8.0%
Avg Opioid Rate

Top Prescribers by Drug Cost

# Provider Drug Cost
1 Weaver Lindsay $44.8M
2 Ravichandran Ashwin $16.8M
3 Yeley Jana $12.4M
4 Machado Roberto $11.8M
5 Fletcher Maria $10.9M
6 Zhang Zhentao $10.7M
7 Pittman Isaiah $10.3M
8 Bedano Pablo $9.5M
9 Bhatia Vishal $8.9M
10 Manges Robert $8.8M
11 Ansari Bilal $8.7M
12 Toole Michael $8.6M
13 Birhiray Ruemu $8.5M
14 Lohano Vasdev $8.5M
15 Bireley Kelly $7.9M
16 Khan Rashid $7.8M
17 Garrett Melissa $7.5M
18 Campbell David $7.5M
19 Bhatia Sumeet $7.4M
20 Al Jebawi Ahmed $7.1M
21 Radadiya Pragneshkumar $7.1M
22 Kristl Kevin $6.9M
23 Brow Jennifer $6.9M
24 Asamoah Ernest $6.8M
25 Myers Emily $6.4M
26 Offerle Andrew $6.3M
27 Bridges Jane $6.3M
28 Crawford Kevin $6.3M
29 Greenspan Andrew $6.2M
30 Ammakkanavar Natraj $6.1M
31 Snook Riley $6.1M
32 Zeitoun Mohamed $6.0M
33 Emmett John $6.0M
34 Muhrez Nihad $5.8M
35 Naqvi Tahir $5.7M
36 Bodkin Cynthia $5.7M
37 Bufill Jose $5.7M
38 Davis Henry $5.7M
39 Mulherin Brian $5.6M
40 Pascuzzi Robert $5.6M
41 Kretchman Erica $5.5M
42 Deshpande Ajay $5.5M
43 Paracha Ibrar $5.5M
44 Goldstein Steven $5.4M
45 Adra Nabil $5.4M
46 Mustaklem Marwan $5.4M
47 Malone Ryan $5.3M
48 Dantzer Brandy $5.3M
49 Braik Tareq $5.3M
50 Conte William $5.2M

Highest Opioid Prescribing Rates

# Provider Opioid Rate
1 Cooke Jeffrey 100.0%
2 Auffrey Amanda 93.9%
3 Dicke Timothy 92.4%
4 Grzegorek Gina Rosario 92.0%
5 Cutcliffe David 90.7%
6 Lippie David 89.7%
7 Graner Kelly 89.5%
8 McCarty Holly 88.5%
9 Pace Louis 87.5%
10 Marburger Ross 87.5%
11 McConnell Kevin 87.5%
12 Bradshaw Rhiannon 87.5%
13 Szotek Paul 87.5%
14 McClain Karen 87.5%
15 Pannunzio Michael 86.5%
16 Fails Cameron 86.3%
17 Buehre Jennifer 86.2%
18 Gordan Bradley 86.0%
19 Overfield Katelyn 85.3%
20 Grabowski Michael 85.2%
21 Reller Olivia 85.2%
22 Plake Cara 85.0%
23 Moore Brian 84.8%
24 Noorzad Sara 84.8%
25 Moser Alexandria 84.7%
26 Atkins Jesi 84.7%
27 Tobias Erin 84.6%
28 Patterson Jonathan 84.6%
29 Hollingshead Erin 84.2%
30 Bond Jo 84.2%
31 Ottinger Lance 84.2%
32 Winters Nicolaus 84.0%
33 Dotterweich William 84.0%
34 Hogg Peter 83.9%
35 Tawadros Atef 83.4%
36 Gootee Kara 83.3%
37 Hillenburg John 83.2%
38 Mahon John 83.1%
39 Culver Samuel 83.0%
40 Casetti Alfredo 82.8%
41 Sibai Tarek 82.6%
42 Almaz Biruk 82.5%
43 Bly Chase 82.2%
44 Bradford Angela 82.1%
45 Fife Luke 82.0%
46 Yurack Darian 82.0%
47 Maatman Thomas 81.8%
48 Nowlin Jenna 81.8%
49 Laboe Patrick 81.3%
50 Janowski Kelly 81.3%

Frequently Asked Questions

How many Medicare prescribers are in Indiana?
Indiana has 26,000 Medicare Part D prescribers who filed 37,138,015 claims totaling $6227.6M in drug costs.
What is the opioid prescribing rate in Indiana?
The average opioid prescribing rate in Indiana is 8.0%. 10273 prescribers in the state have prescribed opioids. The national average is 6.4%.

Compare Prescriber Rankings in Nearby States

Other states with CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber PUF rankings for side-by-side context.

Compare specialties nationally →

Data from CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber Public Use File (Calendar Year 2023); providers identified by NPI from the CMS NPPES registry. PlainDoctor presents this data factually without editorial judgment. Methodology · About

How to read Indiana Medicare prescriber data

The rankings on this page are drawn from the CMS Medicare Part D Prescriber Public Use File and cover providers who submitted prescription drug claims for Medicare Part D beneficiaries in Indiana. High-cost prescribers are not inherently problematic, a high total drug cost most often reflects specialty practice in cancer care, rheumatology, neurology, or HIV/AIDS where the standard of care involves expensive brand-name or biologic medications. Low-cost prescribers serving a primarily elderly primary-care population may prescribe generics almost exclusively, producing a small cost figure that says nothing about the quality of care they provide.

The opioid prescribing rate shows the share of a provider's Medicare Part D claims that were for opioid medications. Context is critical here: pain management specialists, palliative care physicians, and oncologists legitimately maintain higher opioid rates because their patients require it for symptom management. A high opioid rate from a family medicine physician in a county with no pain specialists may also reflect appropriate care for patients who have no other options. These rankings are a transparency resource for researchers and policymakers, not a quality judgment on individual providers.

State-level prescribing patterns in Indiana reflect the state's age distribution, the prevalence of Medicare Advantage versus traditional Medicare, the density of teaching hospitals, and rural versus urban geography. States with older populations and lower Medicare Advantage penetration typically show higher per-capita Part D claims because traditional Medicare beneficiaries generate more claims data than those enrolled in integrated managed-care plans. States with large academic medical centers show more specialty prescribing; states with dispersed rural populations show proportionally more primary-care generalist prescribing.

For any provider appearing in these lists, the PlainDoctor detail page (accessible by clicking the provider name) shows their full NPI record, specialty taxonomy, practice address, and credential history from NPPES. The Part D prescribing data itself is published by CMS with a roughly 18-month lag; the most recent file covers calendar year 2023. For real-time prescribing status or licensure verification, contact the Indiana state medical board or use the CMS NPI Registry directly.

Compare to other states

Medicare Part D prescriber distribution varies dramatically by state due to differences in population age, Medicare Advantage penetration, regional medical-school training pipelines, and rural-versus-urban geography. Browse the equivalent rankings for California, Texas, Florida, New York, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Illinois, Georgia, North Carolina, Michigan, and Washington for the high-volume states. Or jump directly to the prescriber rankings hub and all PlainDoctor rankings.

For specialty-level analysis (which clinician types prescribe most under Medicare Part D), see the top specialties ranking. For population-adjusted comparisons (per-capita prescriber availability), see the top states by provider count page.

Compiled from official public sources by the editorial process.

Every figure on PlainDoctor is rendered directly from the federal CMS NPPES registry, Medicare Part D, MIPS, and Open Payments records, no number is typed in by an editor. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error. Data current as of 2026-05-20.