Doctors and health care providers in Carthage, IL
82 individual NPPES records list a practice address in Carthage, 288th of 541 Illinois cities. The largest group is mental health counselor: 11, 13% of the city's records, against 4% across Illinois. Page 2 of 2.
The 8 largest groups in Carthage
Source: CMS NPPES primary taxonomy, file of Aug 9, 2026.
Carthage in Illinois
- Rank in Illinois288th of 541 cities by records
- Share of the state<0.1% of Illinois's records
- Specialties present25 or more taxonomy codes
- Top three groups26.8% of all records
Compared with Illinois as a whole, Carthage has 3× the state's share of mental health counselor records.
Providers in Carthage, alphabetically
- Michelle Nelson, DCChiropractor1922198910
- Leah NewtonSpeech-Language Pathologist1235654831
- Keela NicholsSocial Worker1518411800
- Nicole NicholsCounselor1902381346
- Rita O'DonnellSocial Worker1487977617
- Gavin O'Neil, LISW, LCSWClinical Social Worker1669152336
- Kelly OvertonMental Health Counselor1730335902
- Randall Peters, MDSurgery Physician1306872320
- Elizabeth Pickering, PA-CPhysician Assistant1659687432
- Duane Prior, D.C.Chiropractor1952313785
- Tiffany RollerLicensed Practical Nurse1952705329
- Katherine RuebushPhysical Therapist1992469522
- Mollie Sanchez, PMHNPPsychiatric/Mental Health Nurse Practitioner1316620628
- Deborah SchusterRegistered Dietitian1942240270
- Michael Schwab, CRNA RNCertified Registered Nurse Anesthetist1295715142
- Kariann SeltzerMental Health Counselor1649901752
- Nileshwa Senthe, M.D.Pediatrics Physician1922261817
- Melanie SharpeMental Health Counselor1962923615
- Louis SistoMental Health Counselor1578873527
- Bobbi SkinnerPsychologist1699377309
- Tiffany SmithAddiction (Substance Use Disorder) Counselor1548480379
- Brock StoutMental Health Counselor1932962313
- Jennifer TeelLicensed Practical Nurse1063930451
- Tammy Teel, MS ED.Professional Counselor1952621922
- Linda Tobias, MT-BCMusic Therapist1760932909
- Daveda Voss, NPFamily Nurse Practitioner1710212535
- Craig WearPharmacist1407486228
- Jeanne WestbyRegistered Nurse1871705772
- Michala Westfall, LSWSocial Worker1679002125
- Nicole WilkensPhysical Therapy Assistant1235914946
- Chelsea Youmans, ARNPPsychiatric/Mental Health Nurse Practitioner1346686193
- Tiffany Youtzy, CRNACertified Registered Nurse Anesthetist1558560680
The largest Illinois cities
- Chicago63,379
- Springfield4,997
- Naperville4,634
- Peoria4,621
- Evanston4,013
How to read this directory
Carthage, Illinois appears in the CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System with 82 registered healthcare providers spanning 25 or more distinct NUCC-taxonomy specialties. This count includes every individual clinician who has applied for an NPI and listed a practice address in Carthage - physicians, dentists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, chiropractors, physical therapists, optometrists, psychologists, podiatrists, and every other credentialed provider type CMS tracks. It does not measure hospital beds, urgent-care capacity, or whether a given clinic is accepting new patients; it measures the pool of professionals with current NPI enrollment and a Carthage practice location on file. Every figure is drawn from the federal National Provider Identifier Registry (CMS NPPES) - more than 7 million providers, maintained since May 2007, with 2024 Medicare Part D data, and, according to CMS, can be searched, compared, and traced in our methodology.
The provider mix in Carthage is weighted toward Mental Health Counselor (11 clinicians, followed by Licensed Practical Nurse with 6 and Physical Therapist with 5). That distribution reflects how NPPES records specialty: providers self-select a primary taxonomy code, so a family physician who also practices geriatrics will show up under whichever NUCC code they registered first. Relative to Illinois's population, Carthage reports roughly 0.7 providers per 100,000 residents using the state-level denominator, which is a rough proxy rather than a precise access-to-care measurement; the true catchment area of any {cityName} clinician extends beyond the municipal boundary.
Of Illinois's most common specialties, Behavior Technician is the most prominent one with no provider currently listing a Carthage practice address, a coverage gap Carthage patients typically fill by traveling to a larger nearby hub.
For Carthage patients, this directory is most useful as a starting shortlist. Important: PlainDoctor is a directory of publicly available CMS government data, not a review site, a ranking, or medical advice. NPPES data is self-reported and refreshed monthly; call the practice directly to confirm the provider is still there, accepts your insurance, and is taking new patients.
For informational purposes only; this directory is not medical advice and not a substitute for checking a license. See also: how to find a doctor and how to verify one.
Common questions
How many doctors are in Carthage, IL?
There are 82 registered healthcare providers in Carthage, IL, covering 25 or more specialties. This includes physicians, dentists, therapists, and other licensed providers.
What are the most common medical specialties in Carthage?
The most common specialties in Carthage are Mental Health Counselor, Licensed Practical Nurse, Physical Therapist, Chiropractor, Social Worker. Mental Health Counselor has the most providers with 11.
Source: CMS National Plan and Provider Enumeration System (NPPES), file of Aug 9, 2026 (NPPES files on CMS.gov). Records are self-reported registrations, not licenses.
Figures on PlainDoctor are read from the federal files each page names (CMS NPPES, Medicare Part D, MIPS, Open Payments; the HHS-OIG exclusion list only as counts) and from Census population estimates, with the file date shown beside them. See our editorial standards & corrections policy, the methodology behind these numbers, or report a data error. Data current as of Aug 9, 2026.