NPPES file of Aug 9, 2026

Nursing Home Deficiencies in Indiana

Indiana's nursing homes average 7.2 health-inspection deficiencies on their latest standard survey, at or below the national 9.2, across 507 surveyed homes. The 100 with the most citations are listed below.

CMS Care Compare nursing home file processed Jul 1, 2026, rating cycle 1 surveys ยท method ยท Care Compare on CMS.gov โ†’

Indiana against the nation

  • Nursing homes507
  • Surveyed507
  • Average deficiencies, Indiana7.2 per home
  • Average deficiencies, U.S.9.2 per home
  • Fines on record, Indiana$4,218,637

Source: CMS nursing home file processed Jul 1, 2026; deficiencies from the most recent standard survey (rating cycle 1).

Most deficiencies in Indiana

#Nursing homeCityDeficienciesComplaintsFinesInspection
1Castleton Health Care CenterIndianapolis38181 of 5
2Aperion Care LincolnEvansville3623$53,4541 of 5
3Robin Run Health CenterIndianapolis29141 of 5
4Hillside Manor Nursing HomeWashington295$12,7401 of 5
5Waters OF Scottsburg, TheScottsburg2823$31,3521 of 5
6Lincolnshire Health & Rehabilitation CenterMerrillville2813$3,4181 of 5
7Munster Med-InnMunster269Not rated
8Waters OF Clifty Falls, TheMadison26111 of 5
9Dyer Nursing And Rehabilitation CenterDyer2410$23,2571 of 5
10Brownsburg Health Care CenterBrownsburg237$31,5401 of 5
11Cardinal Care StrategiesMuncie2391 of 5
12Great Lakes Healthcare CenterDyer2261 of 5
13Rensselaer Care CenterRensselaer2211$128,3111 of 5
14Waters OF Sullivan Nursing Facility, TheSullivan2161 of 5
15Waters OF Castleton Skilled Nursing Facility, TheIndianapolis21101 of 5
16South Shore Health & Rehabilitation CenterGary2181 of 5
17Oak Grove Christian Retirement VillageDemotte2191 of 5
18Ignite Medical Resort Dyer LLCDyer217$8,2811 of 5
19Harcourt Terrace Nursing And RehabilitationIndianapolis20111 of 5
20Plainfield Health Care CenterPlainfield2011$31,8521 of 5
21Signature Healthcare OF MuncieMuncie20101 of 5
22Aperion Care VincennesVincennes19101 of 5
23Aperion Care Arbors Michigan CityMichigan City1971 of 5
24Greencroft HealthcareGoshen1941 of 5
25Hammond-Whiting Care CenterWhiting1931 of 5
26Envive OF River CityEvansville1921 of 5
27Crown Point Health CampusCrown Point199$25,6651 of 5
28Harbor Health & RehabEast Chicago195$29,2301 of 5
29Ignite Medical Resort Crown Point LLCCrown Point1971 of 5
30Waters OF Tipton Skilled Nursing Facility, TheTipton187$20,4941 of 5
31Aperion Care Tolleston ParkGary1861 of 5
32Waters OF Georgetown, TheGeorgetown18101 of 5
33Evergreen Crossing And The LoftsIndianapolis18111 of 5
34Life Care Center OF The WillowsValparaiso1741 of 5
35Waters OF Huntingburg, TheHuntingburg1781 of 5
36Southwood Healthcare CenterTerre Haute177$40,7901 of 5
37Westside Retirement VillageIndianapolis1771 of 5
38Majestic Care OF GoshenGoshen177$16,0361 of 5
39Waters OF Wabash Skilled Nursing Facility East TheWabash1651 of 5
40Waters OF Covington, TheCovington165$319,8781 of 5
41Brickyard Healthcare - Golden Rule Care CenterRichmond169$55,1021 of 5
42River Bend Nursing And RehabilitationEvansville1691 of 5
43Charlestown Place AT New AlbanyNew Albany1611$31,7841 of 5
44Beaumont Rehabilitation And Healthcare CenterAnderson158$14,9011 of 5
45Heritage CenterEvansville1502 of 5
46University Nursing CenterUpland158$74,5851 of 5
47Newburgh Health and RehabNewburgh1521 of 5
48Poplar Care StrategiesLoogootee156$8,0211 of 5
49Terrace AT Solarbron TheEvansville1542 of 5
50Hamilton Trace OF FishersFishers1552 of 5
51Community Nursing And Rehabilitation CenterIndianapolis1410$12,7351 of 5
52Envive OF IndianapolisIndianapolis1421 of 5
53Valparaiso Care & RehabilitationValparaiso1452 of 5
54Hutsonwood AT BrazilBrazil1431 of 5
55Aperion Care DemotteDemotte1421 of 5
56Majestic Care OF North VernonNorth Vernon146$14,0152 of 5
57Homewood Health CampusLebanon1442 of 5
58Brickyard Healthcare - Muncie Care CenterMuncie141$22,3602 of 5
59Aperion Care Marion LLCMarion1451 of 5
60Hamilton Pointe Health And RehabNewburgh1451 of 5
61Ignite Medical Resort ChestertonChesterton1461 of 5
62Mason Health Care CenterWarsaw1341 of 5
63Aperion Care HanoverHanover134$53,8741 of 5
64Waters OF Batesville, TheBatesville1371 of 5
65Waters OF Hobart Skilled Nursing Facility, TheHobart1321 of 5
66Allison Pointe Healthcare CenterIndianapolis133$56,3811 of 5
67Waters OF Dillsboro-Ross Manor, TheDillsboro1342 of 5
68Paoli Health And Living CommunityPaoli133$28,1381 of 5
69Westpark A Waters CommunityIndianapolis1322 of 5
70Holy Cross Rehabilitation And WellnessSouth Bend1372 of 5
71Warsaw MeadowsWarsaw133$105,0731 of 5
72Brickyard Healthcare - Willow Springs Care CenterIndianapolis1342 of 5
73Mcgivney Health Care CenterCarmel130$8,1893 of 5
74Pilgrim ManorPlymouth121$45,5801 of 5
75Brickyard Healthcare - Fountainview Care CenterMishawaka1232 of 5
76Brickyard Healthcare - Portage Care CenterPortage1232 of 5
77Chesterton ManorChesterton1202 of 5
78Waters OF Princeton, ThePrinceton1211 of 5
79Life Care Center OF Michigan CityMichigan City1222 of 5
80Majestic Care OF Deming ParkTerre Haute127$73,6121 of 5
81Brickyard Healthcare - Merrillville Care CenterMerrillville1221 of 5
82Casa OF HobartHobart125$14,4331 of 5
83Lane House, TheCrawfordsville124$175,0651 of 5
84Waters OF Wakarusa Skilled Nursing Facility, TheWakarusa123$14,6611 of 5
85Brickyard Healthcare - Elkhart Care CenterElkhart1251 of 5
86Alpha Home - A Waters CommunityIndianapolis122$22,3861 of 5
87Evansville Protestant HomeEvansville1212 of 5
88Creasy Springs Health CampusLafayette122$8,0182 of 5
89Transcendent Healthcare OF Boonville - NorthBoonville121$253,9551 of 5
90Waters OF Rushville Skilled Nursing Facility, TheRushville1172 of 5
91Waters OF Huntington Skilled Nursing Facility, TheHuntington112$85,4801 of 5
92Vermillion Convalescent CenterClinton1103 of 5
93Spring Mill MeadowsIndianapolis1102 of 5
94Westminster Village NorthIndianapolis1132 of 5
95Waters OF Martinsville, TheMartinsville113$22,1651 of 5
96Chateau Rehabilitation And Healthcare CenterFort Wayne114$109,2571 of 5
97Premier Healthcare OF New HarmonyNew Harmony1111 of 5
98Albany Health Care & Rehabilitation CenterAlbany1152 of 5
99Majestic Care OF Jefferson PointeFort Wayne1171 of 5
100Envive OF SullivanSullivan1132 of 5

Source: CMS nursing home file processed Jul 1, 2026. A count is not a severity: read each home's survey report.

How to read deficiencies

Across the 507 surveyed nursing homes in Indiana, the average facility carries 7.2 total health-inspection deficiencies on its most recent CMS standard survey, compared with a national average of 9.2. A "deficiency" is a specific F-tag citation written by state surveyors during the annual federal inspection under 42 CFR ยง483, each citation maps to a scope-and-severity grid (A through L) that determines whether it is an isolated low-harm issue or a widespread immediate-jeopardy finding. The Indiana state-level average reflects the sum of all F-tag citations divided by the number of facilities; it does not distinguish between low-severity paperwork findings and high-severity resident-harm citations, which is why drilling into any facility's full survey report matters more than the headline count. This page uses 14,693 Medicare-certified nursing-home records from CMS Care Compare, with NPPES context where available. Every figure is traceable in the methodology.

The table below ranks up to the top 100 Indiana facilities by total deficiency count (highest first) - the goal is transparency, not a blacklist. Facilities appear with their deficiency total, complaint-based deficiencies (citations triggered by a formal complaint rather than the routine survey), fine dollar amounts, and CMS Health Inspection component rating. A high count can reflect a facility with genuine quality problems, a more aggressive state survey team, a larger bed count with more opportunities for citation, or a complaint spike in a single cycle, context matters. Conversely, a low count does not guarantee good care; facilities rarely surveyed, or recently surveyed with a favorable cycle, can look clean while problems accumulate between inspections. The state's benchmark of 7.2 deficiencies and the national benchmark of 9.2 (average score 82) are starting reference points.

Deficiencies are based on CMS Rating Cycle 1 (the most recent completed standard survey); prior cycles appear on each facility's detail page. Important: PlainDoctor presents CMS deficiency data exactly as published at data.cms.gov - we do not aggregate, re-rank, or editorialize. This table is a research tool, not medical advice, a consumer rating, or a legal conclusion about any facility. Selecting a nursing home for yourself or a loved one should include in-person visits, reading the underlying F-tag narratives in the full CMS-2567 survey reports, interviewing staff and current residents' families, and consulting licensed clinicians, hospital discharge planners, and elder-law advisors familiar with Indiana long-term care regulations.

Deficiencies in other large states

  1. Texas1,177
  2. California1,165
  3. Ohio922
  4. Florida694
  5. Illinois667

Common questions

What is the average deficiency count in Indiana nursing homes?

Across the 507 surveyed facilities in Indiana, the average is 7.2 health inspection deficiencies per facility, compared to a national average of 9.2. The national average deficiency score is 82.

What types of deficiencies do nursing homes receive?

Deficiencies are F-tag citations issued during CMS standard surveys or complaint investigations. They range from minor paperwork issues (scope A-B) to widespread immediate-jeopardy findings (scope J-L). The severity matters more than the raw count.

How does Indiana compare nationally for nursing home deficiencies?

The Indiana average of 7.2 deficiencies per facility is at or below the national average of 9.2. State survey teams vary in strictness, so cross-state comparisons should be made with caution.

What should I do if a Indiana nursing home has many deficiencies?

Review the severity of individual citations, not just the count. Read the F-tag narratives in the CMS-2567 survey reports, tour the facility in person, interview staff and residents' families, and consult licensed clinicians or elder-law advisors familiar with the state's long-term care regulations.

Source: CMS Five-Star Quality Rating System, Nursing Home Provider Information, processed Jul 1, 2026 (data.cms.gov).